This is the second part of the OVER/UNDERRATED posts. This one may be more controversial because people will take the criticism of their favorite card to heart and get upset. God forbid, someone should touch on the VG Queen Morgane. Anyway, if people can remain civilized and keep their comments tame, then this post will be a success.

Here are the 2 rules: the card must be 8.5 or higher; explain why the card, in your opinion, is overrated.

1. Deny - Hawaii Flower. This card could have been a lot better but Deny does not use her ASSets to her advantage.

2. Nikky Case - Free Time. She seemed bored here, and her self-reservations are clear in this card.

3. Nadine - Hot Cop. She has the serious look to be a cop but an 8.71? C'mon.

4. Bijou - Sunset Blvd. Too much mouthing in this one.

5. Sendy Silver - Spanking Therapy. She has the slutty look to pull it off but her routine is the same as in her other cards. And the paddle is annoying.


What's yours? Thanks.

1. All of Morgane's cards - I don't dislike Morgane and I think she deserves a reasonably high score (around the 8.5 mark at least), but in my view her cards are nowhere near the best on vghd.

2. Natalie Blond "Street Style" - The card with the ***** bottle scene. This card features a lackluster performance that borders on the tedious. The bottle scene is actually the only remotely interesting thing about it.

3. Jan H "Californian Suit" - Jana H is one of those girls who's performances vary between excellent and fairly poor. This card is niether. It's fairly good, but certainly shouldn't be classed among the best.

4. Lea Tyron "Banana Split" - A recent card who's rating may yet go down. For me it's only mediocre and the costume is gareish. It doesn't deserve any more than about 7 in my view.

5. Melisa "West Coast" and "Whipped Cream" - I really like Melisa and these are very good. I just don't think their her best. "Little Poem" deserves to be rated higher than these.

All that being said - I agree completely regarding Nadine and Deny (particularly Nadine) - two girls who look fantastic, but who's performances just don't match up. Nadine in particular just seems as if she wants to be somewhere else in all her shows.

Well, I'll say that this is a weird subject anyway. That would be because there is NO SUCH THING as an overrated card. High ratings come from more people preferring a card and lower ratings only mean that less people prefer that card. It is nothing different than that. If you feel that something is overrated in your opinion, then it is just that, your opinion. It simply means that if you prefer something different than the majority of the people, you are then in the minority of all in general. That's all, just as simple as that.

@wildone
The sad fact is, however, that cards can be unjustly rated, because people can post ratings without even buying the card or seeing the show, just on the strength of a few pictures. Like rating a film from only looking at the poster outside the cinema.

Also it is far too easy for unscrupulous users with too much time on their hands set up multiple accounts in order to arrange ratings attacks.

So while your comments would be correct if the vghd rating system was in any way fair. It unfortunately isn't.

That bottle scene is ridiculous because people act as if it is the most explicit on the internet. And it is the only thing people speak of when they speak about Natali. Her shows are overrated because she does not have a connection with the audience. I know most people don't care about her eyes, but she keeps them above the camera almost all the time, and it's like she is being directed entirely. It's a big turn-off.

Little Poem is okay. The big gripe there is the stockings.

Bijou the Amazonian princess would get a 10 from me with all her cards but besides the mouth thing and the limited moves, she tends to be goofy but not goofy in a seductive way like Jenni Gregg. She makes me laugh more than any other girl.

I agree with Nadine. She moves like an elderly and also seems to be going "Is this enough? Am I done?" I don't mind the stone face expression but she is quite emotionless in her shows.

I agree there. Non-purchasers shouldn't be able to rate cards, but other than that, the majority of people is that, the majority of the people.

hm, i can only agree about Nadine. She looks good but you got the strong feeling in her shows that she doesn't like what she is doing. And thats why i don't find her shows arousing in any way.
Morgane has very good shows(Flashy Babe) and not so good ones and surely doesn't deserve 9.x ratings for all shows.

@wildone - As SpacePhantom has pointed out, since the ratings can be manipulated by people who have not seen the cards at all then the ratings is highly opinionated, even if the card is said to be bad not by one person but by a consensus. So, there is a such thing as an overrated card and it is not merely preference.

I don't consider this a weird subject because unlike "pick your favorite girl", you have to factor in the shady rating system, the ability to rate a girl without seeing the card among other factors.

Also, since we can judge objectively, then that too would give some merit to debating whether a card is overrated or underrated or not.

That's basically what I said. Just do eliminate the ability of non-owners of a card from being to be able to vote on a card that they didn't yet purchase. Other than that part, the system isn't really all that bad. Everybody just has to vote with their own honest opinion.

@wildone - But none of that will ever happen. Anyway, this post is simply done out of fun. You do not have to be serious about it.

Everybody is entitled to their opinions, whether they disagree with the majority or not. So we are perfectly entitled to give our opinions on whether we think particular cards are "overrated". It's called freedom of speech.

And on vghd, it's by no means clear that the overall rating of a particular card is the view of the majority of those who bought it anyway.

I know. It is exactly like another post though. It doesn't matter to me that much. I purchase all of them, no matter what.

We have that in common then - I buy all of them as well.

I going back on topic because I find this a very interesting thread.

In theory, every card I own is over-rated since i have never given more than 8. A 10 will be reserved for that card where the girl wears a perfect outfit to my tatse and does a perfectly balanced selection of actions that match closely to my taste.

But with regard to specific cards I do have views based totally on my subjective and dognatic opinion and taste whcih I don't expect anyone to share. Anyway I love spouting about my dogmatic opinions, so here are my 5 in no particular order.

Chems Head Nurse - ***** the outfit except for the stockings anfd the way she uses it. I like her panties but she hardly shows them. Her VGHD rating is cuurentl 8.7 which is well below my rating of 4.

Chems Mint Tea - Not keen on the outfit really. Doesn't do much for me. So again compare a VGHD rating of 8.8 to my 4.

Part 2 coming up.

My dogmatic opinios part 2.

From my earlier post you may think i have it in form Chems. But actually, I love Chems. Its just that I compare everything she does to Sublime beauty, a card that a I like a lot.

Anyway, next three:

Vicky S Golden River - I ***** golden costumes generally so she gets a systematic 1 from me. A bit unfortunate for Vicky S here that I pick on her, but only because it is the only "Golden" card I have, and incidentally I got for free. You may ask, why keep the card. the answer is so that I never ever ever get tempted to but another one. Anyway sorry Vicky. It may help to note that all other Golden card would get 1 out of 10 too.

Zuzanna Confidential - Not very interesting and a huge missed opportunity. Also hides her fantastic beauty. Again she gets a 4 from me compared to a VGHD rating of 8.84.

Tereza Gothic Illusion - No panties, so gets a rating of 3 compared to VGHD's 8.88. I like the costume,but no panties drops the ratings like a rock for me.

Apasas - interesting choices. I am surprised by the Vicky S choice though. I thought she looked adorable, if not Barbie-doll-ish, in that outfit.

Zuzana - While I agree with you, you have to agree that she fits the theme more than any other girl.

Chems Head Nurse - Definitely agree about the outfit. A scrub or a realistic nurse outfit would do better.

Thanks for participating! :)

I think everyone should be allowed to voice their views. It is a good thread. As long as they are not offensive. And in fact, the cards I have crtisised the most belong to girls that I really like. Probably reflecting a dissapointment on my part that they weren't as good (for me at least) in these cards to other cards I have of theirs.

My choice of the Vicky S card does not reflect her performance or her looks. I haven't even watched the card. It just reflects the fact that I ***** golden costumes.

With regards to the secretary costume, I much prefer Lucynova's "Young Secretary". I also think I would prefer Ashley's Robbin's Sexy Secretary, although I don't have it yet. its not so much the performance. I just don't like her skirt. It should be short and tight fitting, just like Lucynova's.

My judgement of Zuzanna's confidential is again coloured by her perforance and costume in "Striking Beauty" which I really liked. I thought Confidential was a step down compared to that.

@Apasas
I think your absolutely right that seeing a card as "overrated" is largely based on disappointment. Of the 5 girls I listed, I would say I actually really like four of them, and certainly don't dislike the other. I just think in these shows that the girls have not performed to their full potential, and that I've seen lower rated shows that are considerably better - some a lot lower rated.

C'est pas vrai les cartes de Morgane ne sont pas "orverrated". C'est juste que tout le monde aime bien lui mettre 10/10 lol.

Most overrated in my opinion are:-
1. Morgane. She has one of the nicest bodies on VGHD but her shows are not up to scratch.
2. Jana H. She is pretty too but she has too much silicone. Her show Movie Star is ordinary to say the least closely followed by Californian Suit.
3.Nikky Case. I find her shows hard to watch. There are so many lower rated cards I enjoy so much more.
4. Jenni Gregg. Gorgeous but overrated.
5. I can't decide who gets this spot Zuzana, Nadine or Ashley Robbins

OMG not again-when do people get enough wisdom to understand-concentrate only about the positive thingies and forgot anything bad as quickly as possible.. as long you don't forgot the way to avoid making the exact same mistake again.
Its much healthier to remember about the wet-dreams-come-truth than to let other live through disappointing nightmares over and over again.
If someone dislike a show thats already enough details somebody else really needs to know..unless you have no own opinion and distrust your own taste by default.
Is much better to make yourself a complete fool by sharing any lovely detail you are hooked to and all thingies that made you happy and horny..
As to bother other people boringly over and over again personal dislikes or *****.Its a poison for your karma and hardly a blessing for anybody else.
I you have completely nothing nice to say you won't make anything worser by just keeping the noise down.
bothering about rating at all its a pointless time waster.
peace